Vital Football

Latest Barnsley FC News

Barnsley FC's Biggest Mistake

Barnsley FC's Biggest Mistake

Ever the optimist (and realist) I appreciate that a club the size of Barnsley FC must have its limits, to that extent I have been fairly satisfied with our last six seasons in championship mid table obscurity, whilst building financial stability. It's also easy as a fan of a typical lower league club to join in the contradictory oneupmanship of 'my teams worse than yours'. As you can guess it was pre 2006 where I think Barnsley's biggest mistakes occurred.

I'm going back a few years to a period of time after Barnsley's relegation from the premier league in 1998, to the sacking of Dave Bassett in 2000. Mistakes were made which nearly ended the clubs existence and almost sent us to the fourth tier of English football. It's surreal to think between 1996 and 2000 Barnsley not only enjoyed promotion and a year in the top tier of English football, but were a top of the table division one side able to attract the best players at that level. Perhaps we were victims of this success, we had tasted premier league football, the board had seen the financial rewards of a sold out Oakwell with plenty of interest around the old mining town.

I'm not suggesting for a moment that Dave Bassett was the saviour, that he was going to lead the club to everlasting success. Rather, with hindsight of the last 13 years, he was doing an admirable job with a 'small club'. The sacking of Dave Bassett, the recruitment of Nigel Spackman, recruiting players we couldn't afford and selling them on soon after. These are the biggest mistakes Barnsley FC have made during my time.

After relegation, the Barnsley board wanted a swift return to the premier league promise land, they paid £800,000 to bring Craig Hignett in to spearhead the push for promotion in 1999 before selling him to Blackburn a year later for £2.2m. This being a big indicator of the financial difficulties around the corner. We had taken a punt, missing out on promotion was not acceptable for the Barnsley board. We got greedy. That thirst for success and promotion led to impatience, Dave Bassett was sacked after 19 months in charge despite leading the reds to a play-off final in 1999/2000 after a third place finish. Nigel Spackman replaced Bassett to carry the promotion baton. The reds were relegated in 2002 to the third tier of English league football.

The ramifications of those mistakes starting in 1998 lead the reds to a watershed moment in 2002. In that season Barnsley entered administration and were on the cusp of liquidation, in a league one relegation battle. Thankfully a deal was agreed to keep the club in business, and the reds survived back to back relegations by the skin of their teeth.

Barnsley FC's biggest mistake wasn't showing ambition, it was trying to gain quick success and results without the right foundations in place. After this time Barnsley have rebuilt on the field and in the purse strings, to a stage where we can learn from the mistakes of the past and perhaps push on for more successful times in the future.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Vital Tyke
Date:Wednesday April 24 2013
Time: 7:33PM


I remember the play off final against Ipswich down at the old Wembley (one of the last games before they pulled it down) 35,000 Tykes fans in attendance...unfortunately we lost, but had we won, things could have been very different, sadly we went down hill from there, but the foundations are being built now for (hopefully) future success..?
25/04/2013 13:15:00
i agree foundations are much better, and the facilities are much admired. unfortunately unless we can achieve bigger gates,then we will be unable to built a team and stick with it. we will always have to buy and sell and also sell our quality youngsters.ideally we should build a team around these, but the books have to be balanced and unless we get more fans through the gates,we have no option.
torrox tyke
25/04/2013 17:28:00
I remember it well, most notably the belief after hignetts opener and the reality of being outclassed by Jim Magilton most notably. True points, Flitcroft does strike me as being that type of charismatic cult figure who could bring back the crowds though?
25/04/2013 21:10:00
Flicker is certainly building foundations and is capable of giving us a bright future. I just don't see what will pull the crowds back in if this run can't?
30/04/2013 19:51:00
If the job can be finished with 3 points at Huddersfield and flicker signs a long term deal, I think the response from the fans next season could surprise a few! Despite the miraculous run we've still been in the relegation mix, this belief with a clean slate could see the crowds return. Fans are fickle, success breeds crowds!
30/04/2013 21:37:00
Fans are fickle. I think we need to be challenging in the top half of the Championship to bring them back.
30/04/2013 21:54:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Recent Barnsley Articles

Stats: Barnsley v Bristol City

All the stats from Barnsley (2) vs (2) Bristol City, Oakwell, 30/3/18 Att: 12,236

Barnsley's International Quartet

Four Barnsley players have received the call from their countries this month and could be on the international stage in March.

Stats: Barnsley v Millwall

All the stats from Barnsley (0) vs (2) Millwall, Oakwell, 17/3/18 Att: 13,041

Who Makes Giggs' First Welsh Squad?

New Wales manager Ryan Giggs has now announced his first selection since taking the job on.

Barnsley Archived Articles

Vital Barnsley articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Barnsley
Write For Vital Barnsley
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

Bristol City MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Williams0%
Sub - Hammill0%
Sub - McCarthy0%
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Barnsley Results (view all)

Barnsley Fixtures

Write for Vital Football