UK time is: 18:55:13
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

It Was Not A Penalty

Well, we didn`t half roll over like a sick dog, albeit after 42 minutes of containing Newcastle.

I`m still divided on whether or not to blame the entire team for the second half collapse, or the referee for not spotting the dive by Lovenkrands.

At first sight it looked like a dive. After reviewing it on video countless times it still looks like a dive.

The fact that there was no contact between Steele and Lovenkrands is undisputed. Lovenkrands came out later and admitted that. He is still adamant however, that the referee got the decision right, because Steele "broke his stride."

I`m sorry, but I`ve watched it over and over and although if it had been our penalty I wouldn`t care, I feel I have to express my opinion on the matter. It is a terrible dive. Luke Steele was nowhere near him and Lovenkrands threw himself to the ground.

Whether the referee thought there was contact or not, it was never a penalty. The referee, according to Mark Robins has cited the F.A. Rule: "A direct free kick is awarded to the opposing team if a player trips or attempts to trip an opponent." So, having established that Steele did not have any physical contact with Lovenkrands (confirmed post-match by Lovenkrands himself) we are left with the assumption that Steele "attempted" to trip him. This is also nonsense. Steele has definitely not attempted to trip him up and neither has he broke his stride. Lovenkrands was looking for the penalty. How can someone running towards you and breaking your stride be against the rules?

Don`t get me wrong, I`m not saying that the penalty meant that we lost the game, or it meant that we lost heavily because it didn`t. Nobody knows what would have happened if it hadn`t been given, or if Steele hadn`t been sent off. I`m saying that the decision in itself, to give the penalty was wrong and so was the subsequent decision to dismiss Steele.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer: gooderzone Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday March 8 2010

Time: 8:00PM

Your Comments

Poor ref decision
Tiny T
Until the FA get serious about stamping out diving, there will always be bad decisions. Rugby league here in Oz has the match review panel which can ban players even if the ref misses an incident during the game. Start handing out suspensions to players who dive, and I believe it would soon stop.
temaze10
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Barnsley Articles

Stats: Barnsley v Colchester (Monday November 17 2014)

Stats: Sheff Utd v Barnsley (Monday November 3 2014)

Sheff Utd v Barnsley Oct 1998 (Saturday November 1 2014)

Barnsley v Sheff Utd March 1997 (Saturday November 1 2014)

Sheff Utd v Barnsley December 1996 (Saturday November 1 2014)

Barnsley v Sheff Utd Past Results (Saturday November 1 2014)

Head-to-head v Sheff Utd (Saturday November 1 2014)

Barnsley v Sheff Utd April 1999 (Saturday November 1 2014)

Barnsley v Sheff Utd November 1999 (Saturday November 1 2014)

Sheff Utd v Barnsley March 2000 (Saturday November 1 2014)

Archived Barnsley Articles

List All Vital Barnsley Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
8. Rochdale 16 8 2 6 13 26
9. Oldham 17 6 8 3 5 26
10. Fleetwood 17 7 4 6 3 25
11. Barnsley 16 6 4 6 0 22
12. Port Vale 17 6 4 7 -1 22
13. Bradford 17 6 4 7 -1 22
14. Chesterfield 17 5 6 6 -1 21

Breaking League News

Hickford joins Boreham Wood
MK Dons : 21/11/2014 18:42:00
Sheffield United v Oldham Athletic
Sheff Utd : 21/11/2014 18:00:00
Team News; Sheffield United v Oldham
Oldham : 21/11/2014 17:48:00
Cup Details Announced
Oldham : 21/11/2014 17:46:00
Clough Expecting Tough Oldham Test
Sheff Utd : 21/11/2014 17:42:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Where Will Barnsley Finish?
Suggested By:  
Top 6%
Top 2 2%
Play Offs 14%
Top Half 27%
Bottom Half 34%
Relegation 12%
Bottom 5%